top of page


Established in 2007, Home Plate Dairy, a family owned & operated ice cream & grilled food shop, opened in the Warren County community. Formerly known as Custer's Last Stand, which dates back to the 1960's, Home Plate continues some of the long standing traditions known to many like our signature soft serve Black Raspberry ice cream and our

Red Eye Shakes (Birch Beer Shake)

Try our "NEW "Choc. Cookie Sandwich.....Sure to be a hit!

We also make our own ice cream cakes customized for your special occasion.

Check out our made to order delicious grill favorites like steak sandwiches, burgers, sausage, pepper & onions, hot dogs,& pork roll. Our signature P'Burger sandwich (1/4 lb cheeseburger topped with pork roll) 

or try our  Buffalo Chicken Steak Sandwich 

Home Plate Dairy is a pet friendly spot which is known for our "pup" cup. Your dog will be begging to come!

We are a seasonal operation from spring to early fall


Home Plate Dairy is now closed for the 2022 season

  Our picnic grove is open with picnic tables  or bring your own blanket & picnic in the grove!

Call us at 908-859-1725

for contactless ordering & pick-up!


bottom of page